Some Fish Shouldn't Climb Trees

I was staring at his forecast, and something didn’t make sense. We were deep into building his financial model, and we’d reached the headcount tab, one of the most important sections, given how much of a company’s budget is tied to payroll. Most headcount forecasts I see look like this:

But his looked like this:

I couldn’t wrap my head around it. So many of his employees were jumping from junior roles to intermediate roles, then again into more senior ones, often across entirely different functions. It looked messy. Unstructured. Almost improvised.
But it wasn’t until years later, when we met up in person, that it all clicked.
For context, this is a CEO who’s built and sold multiple 7-figure businesses. A seasoned operator who doesn’t guess. He sees things others miss.
“You know our Director of Operations?” he asked me. “The one you’ve worked with for five years now and always rave about?”
I nodded.
“He actually started here as an account executive, and he was doing really poorly. But I saw something in him. I knew he wasn’t bad. He was just in the wrong seat. And the moment we made the switch, everything changed.”
I’ve seen this play out so many times since. Someone underperforming in one role but thriving in another. And yet most people, most managers, miss it. They label someone as good or bad, and that’s the end of it. But it’s not that simple. As leaders and professionals, our job is to zoom out, spot the real strengths, and stop letting the wrong fit mask someone’s potential.
See the Hidden Talents in Your Team
After three years of working together, I was thrilled we were finally meeting in person.
He was the most impressive CEO I’d ever worked with, partnering with Fortune 500s, solving complex problems like it was second nature.
I had a list of 50 questions ready to go, and I was firing them off like a kid grilling his childhood hero.
He smiled, answering each one effortlessly.
At one point, I asked, “I noticed a lot of people on your team switch roles over time. What’s up with that?”
He nodded. “That was always something I was good at,” he said. “Early in my career, I’d rate everyone on my team a 9 or a 10. People would push back: ‘Seriously? This person is barely a 4.’ But I wasn’t rating them on everything. I was rating them on what they were great at. And if they weren’t doing well, it just meant they were in the wrong role.”
That stuck with me.
Great leaders don’t just plug people into roles based on need.
They take the time to understand what someone is naturally good at (how they think, how they work, what lights them up) and they build around that.
If you’re a manager, a founder, or hope to be one someday, this might be one of the most important skills you’ll ever develop.
No one is good at everything.
But everyone is great at something.
Your job is to uncover it, and align it with what your business needs most.
Where Do You Shine?
I almost made a huge mistake early in my career, one I still shiver thinking about.
If you’ve followed my content, you probably know I got laid off from my very first job out of college.
I was doing taxes at a Big Four accounting firm.
What I didn’t realize at the time was that I hated everything about taxes: the dense research, the hyper-technical language, the obsessive attention to detail.
I wasn’t just bad at it. I was miserable.
But here’s where I went wrong: I took that failure as a sign that I wasn’t cut out for accounting at all.
For years, I carried that belief. I thought I was the problem.
It wasn’t until much later, when I found myself thriving in forecasting, financial modeling, working with data, and collaborating with stakeholders, that I finally understood: I was meant for this field.
Just not for that corner of it.
Since then, I’ve had the chance to hire over a hundred employees and contractors.
I’ve seen countless friends get laid off from one job, only to land somewhere else and rise to partner.
If you’re feeling stuck, or unsure about where your career is going, here’s what I want you to hear loud and clear:
You are not the problem. You are not a failure.
You are capable of greatness, but only when you align your work with what makes you come alive.
And when there’s a strong business need for it? The Japanese call that Ikigai:

Don’t settle.
Don’t force yourself into a role that doesn’t fit.
The things you’re great at are usually the things you enjoy.
Chase them relentlessly. That’s where the magic happens.
Putting it all together

There’s a simple reason most people never figure this out, and in my opinion, it’s one of the most important skills you can master, whether you’re an employee or an entrepreneur:
Pivoting.
Knowing when to change direction.
Knowing how to change direction.
Testing. Learning. Adapting. That’s what strong CEOs do: they constantly run experiments, analyze results, and evolve.
But the same applies to you. Resilience is one of the most powerful traits I’ve seen in any professional. The more adaptable you are, the stronger you become.
So I’ll leave you with this:
Have you ever failed in one area only to thrive in another?
Have you ever admitted defeat in one role and found excellence in a different one?
I’d love to hear your story. And in a future email, we’ll go deeper into how to recognize when it’s time to pivot.
Have a great weekend.

Josh (Your CFO Guy)
Thanks for reading my article. My goal is to help you grow in your career with proper Finance and Accounting.
If we're not already connected on Social media, let's get connected and send me a message to say hi. I promise to respond




